Boris Shturmer

{{Short description|Prime Minister of the Russian Empire in 1916}} {{family name hatnote|Vladimirovich|Shtyurmer|lang=Eastern Slavic}} {{Infobox officeholder | honorific_prefix = '''Baron''' | name = Boris Shturmer | native_name = {{No bold|Борис Штюрмер}} | native_name_lang = ru | image = Штюрмер Б. (Новгородская область).jpg | order = 5th | office = Prime Minister of Russia | monarch = Nicholas II | term_start = 2 February 1916 | term_end = 23 November 1916 | predecessor = Ivan Goremykin | successor = Alexander Trepov | order2 = Minister of Foreign Affairs of Russia | term_start2 = 7 July 1916 | term_end2 = 10 November 1916 | predecessor2 = Sergey Sazonov | successor2 = Nikolai Pokrovsky | order3 = Minister of the Interior of Russia | term_start3 = 3 March 1916 | term_end3 = 7 July 1916 | predecessor3 = Alexei Khvostov | successor3 = Aleksandr Khvostov | order4 = Yaroslavl Governor | term_start4 = 30 July 1896 | term_end4 = 10 August 1902 | predecessor4 = Alexey Fride | successor4 = Alexey Rogovich | order5 = Novgorod Governor | term_start5 = 14 April 1894 | term_end5 = 30 July 1896 | predecessor5 = Alexander Molosolov | successor5 = Otton Medem | birth_date = {{birth date|1848|7|27|df=y}} | birth_place = Baykovo, Tver Governorate, Russian Empire | death_date = {{death date and age|1917|9|2|1848|7|27|df=y}} | death_place = Petrograd, Petrograd Governorate, Russia | alma_mater = Saint Petersburg State University }}

Baron '''Boris Vladimirovich Shturmer'''{{efn|Also spelled '''Shtyurmer''', '''Stürmer''' or '''Sturmer'''}} ({{langx|ru|Бори́с Влади́мирович Штю́рмер}}; {{OldStyleDate|27 July|1848|15 July}} – {{OldStyleDate|2 September|1917|20 August}}) was a Russian lawyer, a Master of Ceremonies at the Russian Court, and a district governor. He became a member of the Russian Assembly and served as prime minister in 1916. A confidant of the Empress Alexandra, under his administration the country suffered drastic inflation and a transportation breakdown, which led to severe food shortages. During the course of his career, he was Minister of Internal Affairs and Foreign Minister of the Russian Empire.

== Biography == Stürmer was born into a landowning family in Baykovo, Kesovogorsky District, Tver Governorate. His father Vladimir Vilgelmovich Stürmer was of German descent and a retired Captain of Cavalry in the Imperial Russian Army. His mother was Ermoniya Panina.

A graduate of the Faculty of Law, Saint Petersburg State University in 1872, Stürmer entered the Ministry of Justice, the Governing Senate and the Interior Ministry. He was appointed in 1879 as Master of the Bedchamber at the Russian Imperial Court.

===Governor=== In 1891 he became chairman of the district council in Tver. An appointment as Governor of Novgorod in 1894 and Yaroslavl in 1896 followed. Stürmer avoided any clash with the zemstvo, remaining patient.<ref>https://archive.org/stream/featuresandfigur011843mbp#page/n209/mode/2up/search/Sturmer Vladimir I. Gurko (1939) Features And Figures Of The Past Covernment And Opinion In The Reign Of Nicholas]</ref><ref>Paul N. Miliukov (1978) ''The Russian Revolution I'', p. 16. Academic International Press</ref> In a very delicate situation he declared himself a "conservative not out of fear but out of conscience".<ref name="bezh-citi.ru">{{Cite web |url=http://bezh-citi.ru/izvestn/147-shtjumer.html |title=Штюрмер Борис Владимирович |access-date=2015-01-29 |archive-date=2015-02-06 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20150206130209/http://bezh-citi.ru/izvestn/147-shtjumer.html |url-status=dead }}</ref>

In 1902 Vyacheslav von Plehve, the Minister of Interior appointed him as Director of the Department of General Affairs at the Ministry of Interior. After Plehve was killed, Stürmer was willing to succeed him. The tsar even signed a ukase to that effect, yet the post eventually went to Prince Svyatopolk-Mirsky. Stürmer was then admitted into the State Council of Imperial Russia in 1904. This appointment was an "absolutely exceptional example in the history of the Russian bureaucracy". He did not have the formal service qualification necessary for such a high appointment to hold the post of minister or the rank of senator.{{citation needed|date=October 2023}} After Bloody Sunday (1905) again Stürmer was mentioned to become Minister of Interior. Stürmer became close friends with Alexei Bobrinsky. He dreamed of "autocracy, located in combination with the constitutional regime". Stürmer was one of those representatives of the bureaucratic elite, who preferred to distance themselves from the extreme right. Few members of the Council of State could boast of such a relationship with the monarch.

In the State Council, he supported Pyotr Stolypin and his closest collaborators on agrarian reform, land management and agriculture Chief Governor Alexander Krivoshein "in their endeavors in the field of devices peasants". Stürmer, being a dualist, opposed, on one hand, the Black Hundreds, speaking for unlimited autocracy, and the other – the Octobrists and the Kadets, to practice the idea of parliamentarism. Stürmer believed that the division of bureaucrats on the right and liberals required a very cautious attitude.

In the 1913 countrywide celebrations of the Romanov Tercentenary, he accompanied the tsar and his family on a journey to Tver. In autumn of the same year, he was appointed as mayor of Moscow as the candidate from the left was unacceptable to the tsar. He became a member of the Domestic Patriotic Union (OPS) – a moderately right-monarchist organization, founded in 1915. In November 1915 it was proposed the old prime minister Ivan Goremykin should be replaced by Alexei Khvostov. Though on 18 January 1916 the tsar invited Stürmer to discuss the possibility of a new job.

===Prime minister=== right|thumb|Boris Vladimirovich Stürmer (1913)

Stürmer petitioned Nicholas II to sanction the change of his German-surname to Panin.<ref>[http://www.alexanderpalace.org/letters/january16.html Letters of Nicholas II to his wife, Jan. 1916]</ref> Since the Panins were a distinguished family of Russian nobility, the monarch could not agree to Stürmer's request until he had consulted all members of the Panin family. The tsarina and Grigori Rasputin had the opinion it was not necessary for Stürmer to change his name.<!--His German name was regarded as as a risk --> Pending these proceedings, Stürmer was appointed prime minister on 20 January 1916, following the 76-year-old Ivan Goremykin, who was opposed to the convening of the Duma. Nicholas ordered the new prime minister to "take all measures" to ensure that "the government avoided any conflicts with the State Duma", and gave "specific instructions" to "improve relations between the government and the Romanovs".

On the eve of the opening of the Duma, the Prime Minister told Mikhail Rodzianko that "the government is ready to make a concession to the Progressive Bloc, provided that the unit itself is also ready to make compromises". It was a shift to the left; they expected he would launch a more liberal and conciliatory politics.<ref name="bezh-citi.ru"/> The Duma gathered on 9 February 1916. The deputies were disappointed when Stürmer held his speech, as the politicians tried to bring the government under the control of the Duma.<ref>O. Antrick, (1938) "Rasputin und die politischen Hintergründe seiner Ermordung", p. 79, 117.</ref> For the first time in his life, the tsar had made a visit to the Tauride Palace, which made it practically impossible to hiss at the new prime minister.

"As Director of his Secretariat Sturmer selected {{ill|Manasyevich-Manuilov|ru|Манасевич-Мануйлов, Иван Фёдорович}}. This choice, which is regarded as scandalous, is significant."<ref>[http://net.lib.byu.edu/estu/wwi/memoir/FrAmbRus/pal2-06.htm Memoirs by Paléologue]</ref> "The extreme right-wing deputy (A.I. Savenko, a leader of the Black Hundreds) could declare at the session of the Duma on February 29, 1916:

{{cquote|What a terrible thing it is for the country that, during the time of the greatest trials experienced by our fatherland, the country does not trust the government; no one trusts the government, even the right does not trust the government – in fact, the government does not trust itself and is not sure about tomorrow.<ref>[https://www.marxists.org/archive/cliff/works/1976/lenin2/ch05.htm#n44 Cherniavsky, p.18]</ref> }}

A strongly prevailing opinion that Rasputin was the actual ruler of the country was of great psychological importance.<ref>Vladimir I. Gurko (1939) "Features and Figures of the Past", p. 10. [https://archive.org/stream/featuresandfigur011843mbp#page/n33/mode/2up]</ref> <!-- according to D. Lieven not what he did, but how he was perceived.-->Alexei Khvostov and Iliodor concocted a plan to kill Rasputin. Khvostov created the rumour <!--accused Rasputin of working for a separate peace. -->suggesting that Alexandra and Rasputin were German agents or spies.<ref>Kerensky, p. 160</ref><ref>Nelipa, p. 163-164</ref><ref>Vyrubova, pp. 289–290</ref><ref>Moe, p. 387.</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.alexanderpalace.org/alexandra/XXIII.html|title=The Life and Tragedy of Alexandra - Chapter XXIII - Before the Storm|access-date=27 December 2014}}</ref> Evidence that Rasputin actually worked for the Germans is flimsy at best.<ref>Radzinsky asserted that it was the Germans who had spread the rumor that Rasputin was being told military secrets by the "'''debauched German tsarina''".Nelipa, p. 162, 505</ref><ref>King, p. 258</ref><ref>Pares, p. 400.</ref> Rather paranoid, Rasputin went to Alexander Spiridovich, head of the palace police, on 1 March. He was constantly in a state of nervous excitement. Khvostov had to resign within a week and Boris Stürmer was appointed in his place. <!--For Rodzianko Khvostov had broken his neck in combating the Rasputin clique and Stürmer would become a dictator with full powers. Nelipa, pp. 63-64. By Ukaz, his assistant Stepan Petrovich Beletsky was to be sent to Irkutsk, but the appointment was cancelled after the story was revealed in a newspaper. Rasputin, p. 104</ref><ref>Moe, p. 386. Did he become a senator? Nelipa, p. 63.-->In the same month Minister of War Alexei Polivanov, who in his few months of office had brought about a recovery of the efficiency of the Russian army, was removed and replaced by Dmitry Shuvayev. Because of the stresses of war on an inefficient government and at random politics, bureaucracy, zemstvos, in two months of office Stürmer succeeded in making the public want Goremykin back.<ref name="net.lib.byu.edu">[http://net.lib.byu.edu/estu/wwi/memoir/FrAmbRus/pal2-08.htm Memoirs by Paléologue]</ref> According to Maurice Paléologue he had a taste for history, particularly the anecdotal and picturesque side of history.<ref name="ReferenceA">[http://net.lib.byu.edu/estu/wwi/memoir/FrAmbRus/pal2-09.htm Memoirs by Paléologue]</ref> Again according to Paléologue Stürmer consulted Anna Vyrubova about everything.<ref name="net.lib.byu.edu"/> The French ambassador was aghast, depicting Stürmer as "worse than a mediocrity – a third rate intellect, mean spirit, low character, doubtful honesty, no experience, and no idea of state business".<ref>Walter G. Moss, ''A History of Russia: Volume I: to 1917'' (1997) pp 499-504, quote on page 503</ref>

From then everything went down, according to Alexei Khvostov. For War Minister Alexei Polivanov – who both had to leave politics in March 1916 – it was the beginning of the end.<ref>B. Pares (1939), ''The Fall of the Russian Monarchy. A Study of the Evidence'', p. 318. Jonathan Cape. London.</ref> Stürmer took over the Ministry of Interior. After he was simultaneously acting as Minister of the Interior and Minister of Foreign Affairs, he was regarded by Rodzianko as a "dictator with full powers". Under his administration, the country suffered drastic inflation and a transportation breakdown, which led to severe food shortages.<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.firstworldwar.com/bio/sturmer.htm |url-status=dead |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20020625230647/http://www.firstworldwar.com/bio/sturmer.htm |archive-date=2002-06-25 |title=First World War.com - Boris Sturmer}}</ref> Russia's economy, which had been growing until the beginning of the Great War, was now declining at a very rapid rate. Stürmer was inclined to peace negotiations<ref>[http://encyclopedia.1914-1918-online.net/article/Governments-Parliaments_and_Parties_%28Russian_Empire%29 Governments, Parliaments and Parties (Russian Empire) By Fedor Aleksandrovich Gaida]</ref> but his appointment was received with consternation, as an open affront to the whole nation.<ref>[http://net.lib.byu.edu/estu/wwi/memoir/FrAmbRus/pal2-07.htm Memoirs by Paléologue]</ref> In June the tsar had to decide on the question of Polish autonomy, already academic given that Poland had been occupied by the Germans the previous year. Stürmer and most of his colleagues were more hostile to the idea than ever.<ref>{{Cite web|url=http://net.lib.byu.edu/estu/wwi/memoir/FrAmbRus/pal2-10.htm|title = Maurice Paléologue. An Ambassador's Memoirs. 1925. Vol. II, Chapter X}}</ref> The Minister of Foreign Affairs Sergey Sazonov, who had pleaded for an independent and autonomous Congress Poland, was replaced on 23 July ("Sturmer is secretly carrying on a very active campaign against him"<ref name="ReferenceA"/>). They disagreed on too many questions. "After Sazonov's dismissal Stürmer took the portfolio of Foreign Affairs; <!--(on 23 July)-->the emperor had ordered him to conduct the foreign policy of the Empire on the same principles as before, i.e., in the closest co-operation with the Allied Governments. His activities in this department resulted in the premature declaration of war by Romania, so disastrous for that country and for Russia."<ref>Wikisource:1922 Encyclopædia Britannica/Stürmer, Boris Vladimirovich</ref> <!--In the same month (on the 18th) the Tsar asked his wife not to tell Rasputin about his plans. In August there were rumors Alexandra and Rasputin called for an end of the Brusilov Offensive.<ref>Pares, p. 368</ref><ref>Moe, p. 412.</ref> On 6 October Alexandra asked Rasputin for his blessing on the offensive. Strong pressures on both sides developed to end the war.<ref>[https://books.google.com/books?id=1zelAgAAQBAJ&lpg=PA6&dq=boris%20st%C3%BCrmer%20romania&pg=PA6#v=onepage&q=boris%20st%C3%BCrmer%20romania&f=false Jan Karski (2014) The Great Powers and Poland: From Versailles to Yalta, p. 6. ]</ref>-->In July Aleksandr Khvostov, not in good health, was appointed as Minister of Interior (after the Brusilov Offensive Romania joined the Allies in August and attacked Transylvania). In September <!--16 (O.S.)or 23?--> Alexander Protopopov, <!--and member of the 'creaking' Progressive Bloc--> had been appointed as his successor. Protopopov, an industrialist, and landowner, <!--and a friend of Rasputin. He was widely suspected of contacts with Hellmuth Lucius von Stoedten a German envoy in Sweden and a Warburg banker after visiting France and the UK.<ref>Buchanan, p. 32</ref>--> <!--The food supply became 'the most damnable problem'--> raised the question of transferring the food supply from the Ministry of Agriculture to the Ministry of the Interior. A majority of the zemstvo leaders announced that they would not work with his ministry. His food plan was universally condemned.<ref name="Frank Alfred Golder 2008">Frank Alfred Golder (2008) [https://archive.org/details/documentsofrussi027937mbp ''Documents of Russian History 1914–1917'']. Read Books. {{ISBN|1443730297}}.</ref> In October Vladimir Sukhomlinov was released from prison on the instigation of Alexandra, Rasputin, and Protopopov (on 24 October (O.S) the Kingdom of Poland was established by its occupiers). This time the public was outraged<ref>Figes, p. 286.</ref> and the opposition parties decided to attack Stürmer, his government, and the "Dark forces".<ref>Gytis Gudaitis (2005) ''Armeen Rußlands und Deutschlands im 1. Weltkrieg und in den Revolutionen von 1917 und 1918 : ein Vergleich''. Thesis. Katholische Universität Eichstätt-Ingolstadt. p. 142.</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.newspapers.com/newspage/7820193/|title=The News from Frederick, Maryland · Page 21|work=Newspapers.com|date=15 December 1966 |access-date=27 December 2014}}</ref> For them Stürmer simply let matters drift.<ref>{{Cite web|url=http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/570180/Boris-Vladimirovich-Sturmer|title = Boris Vladimirovich Sturmer &#124; prime minister of Russia| date=12 July 2023 }}</ref> <!--As none of the parties could win the Germans started separate peace talks. Stürmer and Polivanov? tried to negotiate a separate peace with Germany, and in this regard was criticized after Kingdom of Poland (1916–18) became independent on 23 October 1916 (O.S).-->The opposition parties decided to attack Stürmer, his government and the "Dark forces".<ref>Gytis Gudaitis (2005) ''Armeen Rußlands und Deutschlands im 1. Weltkrieg und in den Revolutionen von 1917 und 1918 : ein Vergleich''. Thesis. Katholische Universität Eichstätt-Ingolstadt. p. 142 [https://opus4.kobv.de/opus4-ku-eichstaett/frontdoor/index/index/docId/15]; Nelipa, p. 132.</ref> Since Stürmer has been in power Rasputin's authority has greatly increased. For the liberals in the parliament, Grigori Rasputin, who believed in autocracy and absolute monarchy, was one of the main obstacles.

===Downfall=== On 1 November, Pavel Milyukov, concluding that Stürmer's policies placed in jeopardy the Triple Entente, delivered his famous "stupidity or treason" speech at the Imperial Duma, which had not been gathering since February.<ref>[http://www.alexanderpalace.org/gilliard/XIII.html Alexanderpalace]</ref> He highlighted numerous governmental failures. Alexander Kerensky called the ministers "hired assassins" and "cowards" and said they were "guided by the contemptible Grishka Rasputin!".<ref>''The Russian Provisional Government, 1917'': Documents, Volume 1, p. 16 by Robert Paul Browder, Aleksandr Fyodorovich Kerensky [https://books.google.com/books?id=LzWsAAAAIAAJ&dq=RUSSIA%27S+EVIL+GENIUS+Rasputin&pg=PA16]</ref> Stürmer, followed by all his ministers, walked out.<ref name="Frank Alfred Golder 2008"/> Grand Duke Alexander and his brother Grand Duke George requested the Tsar to fire Stürmer. Even the Tsar had to concede that Stürmer was as much of a red rag to the Duma as to everyone else.<ref>Massie, Robert K., ''Nicholas and Alexandra'', New York, Ballantine Books, 1967, {{ISBN|0-345-43831-0}}.</ref> On 10 November he was sacked, the foreign ministry was temporarily led by his deputy Anatoly Neratov. It appeared to Maurice Paléologue, the French ambassador, Stürmer was a broken man.<ref>[http://net.lib.byu.edu/estu/wwi/memoir/FrAmbRus/pal3-04.htm Memoirs by Paléologue]</ref> Following his resignation, Stürmer ran for a seat in the Fourth Duma.

He was arrested by the Russian Provisional Government after the February Revolution in 1917 and died of uremia in September at the hospital of the Peter and Paul Fortress (or the Kresty Prison).

==Notes== {{notelist}}

==References== {{reflist|2}}

==External links== * {{Cite EB1922|wstitle=Stürmer, Boris Vladimirovich |short=x}} * [http://encyclopedia.1914-1918-online.net/article/shtiurmer_boris_vladimirovich#GND_1049358791 Shti︠u︡rmer, Boris Vladimirovich] * Frankfurter Zeitung [https://www.faz.net/-gpf-8ilxy 25 November 1916]: summary of his ministry (German)

{{s-start}} {{s-off}} {{succession box | before = Ivan Goremykin | title = Prime Minister of Russia | years = 2 February – 23 November 1916 (N.S.) | after = Alexander Trepov}} {{succession box|before=Alexei Khvostov|title=Interior Minister of Russia|years=3 March – 9 July 1916|after=Aleksandr Khvostov}} {{succession box|before=Sergei Sazonov|title=Foreign Minister of Russia|years=20 July – 23 November 1916|after=Nikolai Pokrovsky}}

{{s-end}}

{{Prime Ministers of Russia}} {{Ministers of Internal Affairs (Russia)}}

{{Authority control}}

{{DEFAULTSORT:Sturmer, Boris}} Category:1848 births Category:1917 deaths Category:People from Kesovogorsky District Category:People from Bezhetsky Uyezd Category:Nobility from the Russian Empire Category:People from the Russian Empire of German descent Category:Members of the Russian Assembly Category:Heads of government of the Russian Empire Category:Government ministers of the Russian Empire Category:Members of the State Council (Russian Empire) Category:Governors of Yaroslavl Governorate Category:Lawyers from the Russian Empire Category:Saint Petersburg State University alumni Category:Russian people of World War I Category:Recipients of the Order of Saint Alexander Nevsky Category:Recipients of the Order of the White Eagle (Russia) Category:Recipients of the Order of St. Vladimir, 2nd class Category:Recipients of the Order of St. Anna, 1st class Category:Recipients of the Order of Saint Stanislaus (Russian), 1st class Category:Commanders of the Legion of Honour Category:Officers of the Legion of Honour Category:Recipients of the Order of the Rising Sun, 3rd class Category:Recipients of the Order of the Sacred Treasure, 1st class Category:Commanders of the Order of Saint-Charles Category:Commanders of the Order of Saints Maurice and Lazarus Category:Commanders Grand Cross of the Order of the Polar Star Category:Knights Grand Cross of the Order of Isabella the Catholic