{{short description|American lawyer and officer}} {{for|retired air traffic controller with the same name|Kennedy Steve}} '''Stephen Abraham''' is an American lawyer and officer in the United States Army Reserve. In June 2007, he became the first officer who had served on a Combatant Status Review Tribunal to publicly criticize its operations. He said the evidence provided did not meet legal standard, and the members of the panels were strongly pressured by superiors to find that detainees should be classified as enemy combatants.<ref name=Cbs20070623> {{cite news | url=https://www.cbsnews.com/news/gitmo-panelist-slams-hearing-process/ | title=Gitmo Panelist Slams Hearing Process: Lt. Col. Stephen Abraham Is First Member Of Military Panel To Challenge Guantanamo Bay Hearings | date=June 23, 2007 | publisher=CBS | access-date=2007-06-23 }}</ref><ref name=BostonGlobe20070623/> Abraham served in the Office for the Administrative Review of the Detention of Enemy Combatants.
== Civilian career == Abraham currently works for the Law Offices of Stephen Abraham in Newport Beach, California.<ref name=BostonGlobe20070623/>
== Military career == Abraham was commissioned as an officer in the Intelligence Corps in 1981.<ref name=Affidavit>{{cite web | url=http://www.scotusblog.com/movabletype/archives/Al%20Odah%20reply%206-22-07.pdf | title=Declaration of Stephen Abraham, Lieutenant Colonel, United States Army Reserve, June 14th, 2007 | publisher=United States Supreme Court | date=June 14, 2007 | accessdate=2007-06-25 }}</ref> He served as an intelligence officer during periods of both reserve and active duty, including mobilization in 1990 ("Operation Desert Storm") and twice again following the 9/11 attacks.<ref name=Affidavit/> The ''Boston Globe'' noted he had worked in intelligence.<ref name=BostonGlobe20070623/> As of June 23, 2007, he is a lieutenant colonel.<ref name=Cbs20070623/>
Abraham served with the Office for the Administrative Review of the Detention of Enemy Combatants (OARDEC) from September 2004 through March 2005, both in fact gathering and as a panel member. The Combatant Status Review Tribunals, created to assess the individual detention of each of the 558 captives then present at Guantanamo Bay detention camp, lasted from August 2004 through January 2005. The confirmation of the panels' results, by then Secretary of the Navy Gordon R. England, was finished in March 2005.
== Abraham's affidavit == {{wikisource|Declaration of Stephen Abraham, Lieutenant Colonel, United States Army Reserve, June 14th, 2007}}
''CBS'' quoted from an affidavit Abraham provided for a habeas corpus appeal on behalf of Fawzi al-Odah, a detainee at Guantanamo Bay detention camp:<ref name=Cbs20070623/><ref name=Affidavit/><ref name=TheJurist20070622>{{cite news |author = Mike Rosen-Molina |url = http://jurist.law.pitt.edu/paperchase/2007/06/guantanamo-tribunal-officer-says-csrts.php |title = Guantanamo tribunal officer says CSRTs pressured on 'enemy combatant' rulings |publisher = The Jurist |date = June 22, 2007 |accessdate = 2007-06-25 |url-status = dead |archiveurl = https://web.archive.org/web/20080208154544/http://jurist.law.pitt.edu/paperchase/2007/06/guantanamo-tribunal-officer-says-csrts.php |archivedate = February 8, 2008 |author-link = Mike Rosen-Molina }}</ref> He said
{{blockquote|What were purported to be specific statements of fact lacked even the most fundamental earmarks of objectively credible evidence.}}
He criticized that the CSRTs allowed hearsay evidence, which is not admitted in a court of law. He said it was as if the Guantanamo captives faced "a game of telephone".<ref name=WashingtonPost20070623/>
He noted the poor preparation of the staff who prepared the files, most of whom had little or no training in intelligence, and little means to evaluate the data they were reviewing. He said,
<blockquote>It was well known by the officers in OARDEC that any time a CSRT panel determined that a detainee was not properly classified as an enemy combatant, the panel members would have to explain their finding to the OARDEC Deputy Director. There would be intensive scrutiny of the finding by Rear Admiral McGarrah who would, in turn, have to explain the finding to his superiors, including the Under Secretary of the Navy.<ref name=Affidavit/> </blockquote>
According to the ''Washington Post,'' Abraham felt compelled to make his criticisms public after having heard his former boss, Rear Admiral James M. McGarrah, describe the Tribunal process "fair".<ref name=WashingtonPost20070623>{{cite news | url=https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/06/22/AR2007062202230.html | title=An Ex-Member Calls Detainee Panels Unfair: Lawyer Tells of Flawed 'Combatant' Rulings | author=Carol D. Leonnig, Josh White | newspaper=Washington Post | date=June 23, 2007 | accessdate=2007-06-24 }}</ref>
Fawzi al-Odah was one of many detainees challenging his detention due to dissatisfaction with the CSRT process. Detainees had not been provided with legal counsel or given the opportunity to challenge any evidence presented by the government, which could include hearsay and secret, classified information not available to detainees. His was one of several cases consolidated under ''Boumediene v. Bush'', which in 2007 was proceeding to the United States Supreme Court to challenge CSRTs, as well as the military commissions as created under the Military Commissions Act of 2006.
Abraham's sister had attended a presentation by al-Odah's attorneys about the detainee and the legal issues he and others faced. After she told them that her brother had been a Tribunal officer, they approached Abraham to find out what he thought of the process. Learning of his deep concerns, they asked if he would provide an affidavit.<ref name=BostonGlobe20070623/> The Department of Defense keeps the identities of the Tribunal officers a secret. Soon after Abraham submitted his affidavit to the Supreme Court, it changed its previous decision and decided to accept ''Boumediene v. Bush'' for the 2007-2008 docket.<ref name=Cbs20070623/>
During a telephone interview with CBS News, Abraham defended having made the affidavit:<ref name=Cbs20070623/>
{{blockquote| *I pointed out nothing less than facts, facts that can and should be fixed. *I take very seriously my responsibility, my duties as a citizen.}}
Paraphrasing Abraham, the ''Associated Press'' reported:<ref name=Cbs20070623/>
{{blockquote|Abraham was asked to serve on one of the panels, and he said its members felt strong pressure to find against the detainee, saying there was "intensive scrutiny" when they declared a prisoner not to be an enemy combatant. When his panel decided the detainee wasn't an "enemy combatant," they were ordered to reconvene to hear more evidence, he said.
Ultimately, his panel held its ground, and he was never asked to participate in another tribunal, he said.}}
The ''Washington Post'' reports:<ref name=WashingtonPost20070623/>
{{blockquote|He said he and two fellow panel members were closely questioned by McGarrah and his deputy after they decided that there was not enough evidence to conclude that a prisoner was an enemy fighter, and were then ordered to hold an expanded hearing to reconsider their conclusion.}}
The ''Boston Globe'' reports that more senior OARDEC officials met with the Tribunal members to determine "what went wrong" with the case, after they declined to confirm the captive's "enemy combatant" status during their second, extraordinary Tribunal session.<ref name=BostonGlobe20070623>{{cite news |title = Officer criticizes military tribunals: Affidavit cites problems at Guantanamo Bay |author = Farah Stockman |publisher = Boston Globe |date = June 23, 2007 |url = http://archive.boston.com/news/nation/washington/articles/2007/06/23/officer_criticizes_military_tribunals/ |access-date = 2007-06-24 |url-status = live |archive-url = https://web.archive.org/web/20080724012530/http://www.boston.com/news/nation/washington/articles/2007/06/23/officer_criticizes_military_tribunals/ |archive-date = July 24, 2008 |author-link = Farah Stockman }} </ref> {{Further|No-hearing hearings}}
David Cynamon, one of al-Odah's lawyers, praised Abraham's courage in making the affidavit. He expressed his fears that it was "career suicide" for Abraham.<ref name=Cbs20070623/>
Lt. Cmdr. Chito Peppler, responded to the affidavit by claiming that the Office for the Administrative Review of Detained Enemy Combatant:<ref name=Cbs20070623/>
{{blockquote|...procedures afford greater protection for wartime status determinations than any nation has ever before provided.}}
Peppler also said:<ref name=Cbs20070623/>
{{blockquote|Lt. Col. Abraham provides his opinion and perspective on the CSRT process. We disagree with his characterizations. Lt. Col. Abraham was not in a position to have a complete view of the CSRT process.}}
The ''Washington Post'' quotes officials, who asked for anonymity, who claimed Abraham never raised his concerns with McGarrah, a fact which Abraham disputes.<ref name=WashingtonPost20070623/>
According to the ''Boston Globe'', after Abraham sat on a Tribunal, he was assigned to serve as a liaison officer with the JTF-GTMO teams who were compiling the allegations against the captives for the Tribunals.<ref name=BostonGlobe20070623/> They report that Abraham characterized the JTF-GTMO teams he worked with as:
{{blockquote|...relatively junior officers with little training or experience in matters relating to the collection, processing, analyzing and/or dissemination of intelligence material.<ref name=BostonGlobe20070623/>}}
==A second OARDEC officer comes forward== On October 5, 2007 the lawyers for Adel Hassan Hamad, whose case was consolidated under ''Boumediene v. Bush'', filed an affidavit from a second officer who had served with OARDEC.<ref name=TheGuardian20071006AdelHassanHamadAffidavit> {{cite news | url=https://www.theguardian.com/worldlatest/story/0,,-6975988,00.html | title=Second Army Officer Faults Gitmo Panels | work=The Guardian | author=Ben Fox | date=October 6, 2007 | accessdate=2007-10-08 | author-link=Ben Fox (writer) }}</ref> Like Abraham, this second officer, whose name was redacted from the Supreme Court documents, was also a reservist and an attorney in civilian life. He wrote: "training was minimal" -and- "the process was not well defined".<ref name=TheGuardian20071006AdelHassanHamadAffidavit/> Abraham was allowed to sit on only one Tribunal. The second officer sat on 49 Tribunals.<ref name=TheGuardian20071006AdelHassanHamadAffidavit/>
==Interviews== Abraham agreed to numerous interviews following reporting on his affidavit.<ref name=AndyWorthingtonStephenAbraham> {{cite news |url = http://www.andyworthington.co.uk/2008/12/22/an-interview-with-guantanamo-whistleblower-stephen-abraham-part-one/ |title = An interview with Guantánamo whistleblower Stephen Abraham (Part One) |date = 2008-12-08 |author = Andy Worthington |archiveurl = https://www.webcitation.org/5k8xsK8GS?url=http://www.andyworthington.co.uk/2008/12/22/an-interview-with-guantanamo-whistleblower-stephen-abraham-part-one/ |archivedate = 2009-09-29 |accessdate = 2009-09-26 |url-status = dead |author-link = Andy Worthington }}{{cite news |url = http://www.andyworthington.co.uk/2008/12/22/an-interview-with-guantanamo-whistleblower-stephen-abraham-part-two/ |title = An interview with Guantánamo whistleblower Stephen Abraham (Part Two) |date = 2008-12-30 |author = Andy Worthington |archiveurl = https://www.webcitation.org/5k8xsK8GS?url=http://www.andyworthington.co.uk/2008/12/22/an-interview-with-guantanamo-whistleblower-stephen-abraham-part-one/ |archivedate = 2009-09-29 |accessdate = 2009-09-26 |url-status = dead |author-link = Andy Worthington }}</ref><ref name=TheTalkingDogStephenAbraham> {{cite news |url = http://themoderatevoice.com/47815/interview-with-stephen-abraham/ |title = Interview with Stephen Abraham |publisher = Moderate Voice |date = 2009-09-28 |archiveurl = https://web.archive.org/web/20091002131629/http://themoderatevoice.com/47815/interview-with-stephen-abraham/ |archivedate = 2009-10-02 |url-status = dead }}</ref> Abraham said that most of his work, and that of his colleagues on the Tribunals, was performed in Washington, DC. He traveled to Guantanamo only three times. Abraham said that the allegations in the Summary of Evidence memos were referred to as "evidence", but they did not meet the legal standard for evidence.<ref name=TheTalkingDogStephenAbraham/>
== References == {{reflist}}
== External links == * {{cite news | author=Andrew C. McCarthy | url=http://www.nationalreview.com/articles/221379/profession-v-gitmo/andrew-c-mccarthy | title=The Profession v. Gitmo: Lawyers, military or civilian, see war as just another legal case] | publisher=National Review Online | date=June 25, 2007 | author-link=Andrew C. McCarthy }} * {{cite news |url = http://www.tpmmuckraker.com/archives/003521.php |title = Former Tribunal Head: No Problems With How We Classify 'Enemy Combatants' |author = Spencer Ackerman |date = June 25, 2007 |publisher = TPM Muckraker |url-status = dead |archiveurl = https://web.archive.org/web/20070703204000/http://www.tpmmuckraker.com/archives/003521.php |archivedate = July 3, 2007 |author-link = Spencer Ackerman }} * {{cite news | url=http://www.news-journalonline.com/NewsJournalOnline/Opinion/Editorials/opnOPN49062707.htm | date=June 26, 2007 | title=America's cancer: Gitmo corrodes U.S. interests and image | publisher=Daytona Beach News Journal | accessdate=2007-06-28 |archiveurl = https://web.archive.org/web/20070630171854/http://www.news-journalonline.com/NewsJournalOnline/Opinion/Editorials/opnOPN49062707.htm <!-- Bot retrieved archive --> |archivedate = 2007-06-30}} * {{cite news | url=https://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/23/us/23gitmo.html?fta=y&pagewanted=all | author=William Glaberson | work=New York Times | date=July 23, 2007 | title=Unlikely Adversary Arises to Criticize Detainee Hearings | accessdate=2007-07-29 | author-link=William Glaberson }} * {{cite news | url=https://books.google.com/books?id=Pi-fQGh18eYC&q=inspired+by+bastille+key+replica&pg=PA229 | author=Ron Suskind | publisher=Harper | date=2008 | title=The Way of the World: A Story of Truth and Hope in an Age of Extremism | isbn=9780307371744 | accessdate=2015-04-10 | author-link=Ron Suskind }}
{{DEFAULTSORT:Abraham, Stephen}} Category:Living people Category:Guantanamo Bay attorneys Category:Guantanamo Bay captives legal and administrative procedures Category:United States Army reservists Category:Lawyers from Orange County, California Category:Place of birth missing (living people) Category:United States Army officers Category:Year of birth missing (living people) Category:Military personnel from Newport Beach, California